Topic: Treating the Herxheimer (JH) Flare Reaction
CaliforniaLyme
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 7136
posted
From Roadback.org **************************
Treating the Jarisch-Herxheimer (JH) Flare Reaction
Stuart L. Weg, M.D. is certified by the Amer ican Board of Anesthesiology with added qualifications in pain management.
The observed temporary worsening of clinical status in patients undergoing anti-infective treatment is called the Jarisch-Herxheimer (JH) reaction. It may be referred to by some of the terms listed below. This phenomenon, described in the cover article, is not just present in rheumatologic disease but is common to all forms of anti-infective therapies that I have used for most chronic painful states. This app arent common etiology of all chronic pain and arthritis is not within the scope of this discussion but will be covered in the future.
The JH reaction can take the mild form of sleepiness and fatigue to full blown anaphylactic shock. The timing vari es from almost immediately, as is the case of IV antibiotics, to up to a week or two later. This depends on the rate that toxins are produced and how fast they can be metabolized or eliminated. Drug levels are important, but often cannot explain the timin g of a reaction. In some cases an overwhelming, waterfall effect is present, while in other patients there is a slow, gradual building of symptoms. I have seen cases where adding another unrelated medication caused the antibiotic to become more bioavailable and that precipitated a JH. There are cases where simply changing a single 100 mg daily dose of minocycline to two 50 mg split doses has provoked a JH due to an absorption increase. Reducing, suspending or changing the offending medication is the most obvious treatment. Patients must understand that early signs of the JH reaction may not be present; even the most conscientious and observant physicians may not stop or lower the medication in time to avoid patient discomfort.
The classical discuss ions of a JH describe the presence of bacterial debris or toxins from anti-infective therapies that cause this reaction. This is certainly true, but another byproduct is also formed when cell wall deficient bacteria or L forms are attacked. I have noticed that some JH present as a flu syndrome. Other patients develop purulent drainage from the head and neck, urine and other areas. When I have cultured these patients, I have been able to isolate adult (non L-form) bacteria. Treatment with medications that favor the destruction of L-forms who are unwalled forms will also favor or select for the survival of adult or walled forms of bacteria.1 Microbiologists call this change of the form of bacteria pleomorphism. The ind uction of walled forms of bacteria has been studied and should be kept in mind when considering treating a JH reaction.
Treatment of a JH should be aimed at eliminating toxins from the killed bacteria and destruction of newly induced adult b acteria. Consideration should also be given to the possibility of overgrowth of endemic yeast infections. Often there are symptoms that clinically indicate the presence of histamine. The physician's diagnostic skills and clinical judgment must be called into place to differentiate between a direct toxic reaction versus the appearance of an adult form organism or the more insidious development of yeast overgrowth.
For the ease of the reader, I am classifying the JH reaction into two categories:
1) Acute - life-threatening. These may also be called anaphilactoid.
2) Non-acute or non-life-threatening- not anaphilactoid.
Acute - Life Threatening
The severe acute reactions are probably related to a massive response of the immune system to toxins. There may be a large release of histamine as well. Such anaphilactoid reactions need immediate attention and should be considered life-threatening. The most severe problems involve swelling of the neck areas and closure of the airway. This must be treated at once with epinephrine followed by transportation to a hospital. The management of severe anaphilactoid emergencies is well known by healthcare personnel and beyond the ability of the patients to handle at home. A drop in blood pressure is also common along with skin changes due to dilation of the blood vessels. This can lead to cardiovascular collapse unless aggressively treated and also needs hospital management. Milder cases featuring asthma may respond to inhaled broncodialator medications, but this can sometimes delay the patient from seeking early medical attention and avoiding catastrophe. Skin rashes are not life threatening but often are quite distressing. A more detailed
Anti-infective therapies or approaches that can feature the JH
Antibiotic/antifungal therapies < LI>Oxidative therapies Ozone Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation Hydrogen Peroxide therapy High dose vitamin C therapy Induced Hyperthermia Sunlight exposure Various herbal therapies Bee sting reactions Iodine reacti ons Terms in Use for JH
Herxheimer Reaction Die Off Reaction Flare Reaction Coming Out Reaction Summary of Tre atment Features of Life Threatening JH Reactions
Treatment of histaminic states Acute life threatening histamine shock or airway swelling Epinephrine with fluids for shock Mild JH Reactions
Anti-histamine medication e.g.benadryl parenterally or by mouth Supportive Care for Anaphylactic Type JH Reactions
Management of Bronchospasm (acute asthma) with Bronchodialators
discussion of these kinds of problems is presented in most textbooks of medicine and all manuals for emergency care.
Management of Non-life Threat ening JH Reactions or Clinical Flares
The more typical JH reactions to anti-infective therapies are: worsening of symptoms, febrile states such as night sweats, flu-like picture, hot swollen joints, mental depression and fatigue. I recommend home therapies designed to clear the blood and make the patient more comfortable. My routine calls for baths in hydrogen peroxide and Epsom salts. These baths are very effective and have tremendous anti-infective effects. They may work for only a short time at first and may need to be repeated. The peroxide easily enters the body through the skin and rapidly detoxifies and sterilizes the blood. There will be a marked reduction in tight muscles that can be a part of a JH reaction. Unfortunately peroxide can have a JH reaction of its own, but this is more pronounced when it is used IV rather than in a bath. Magnesium in the Epsom salts also passes easily systematically; it has a local anesthetic, antispasmodic effect and an overall improvement in the performance of most systems. Oral peroxide is available but not discussed here. The IV route for both peroxide and magnesium is used to stop the JH reaction in office management. The same benefit of blood detoxification and general enhanced clearing of tissue toxins and bacteria can be claimed for high dose ascorbic acid (20-50 GMs IV). Vitamin C can be given in oral form too. Ascorbic acid powder equals about 5 grams per level teaspoon. This dose can be taken with water or juice as often as needed or until there is GI intolerance such as diarrhea. The clinical effects are similar to peroxide. In fact, the two can be given to a patient on the same day with excellent results. It must be remembered however; the vitamin C will also neutralize peroxide and thus should always be given after the bath. Mild JH reactions are also seen with vitamin C therapy again mainly when given IV. Such therapies as peroxide baths and vitamin C are easy to do at home and extremely effective at helping patients make a quick, safe recovery from a JH reaction.
Other oxidative office therapies can be alternated with these modalities or with antibiotics to hasten detoxification of bacterial toxins. Ultraviolet blood irradiation (UBI) involves removing a small portion of the circulating blood and cleaning it under UV light before returning it to the patient. The mechanism of action is not well known, but such treatment has been used for over fifty years mostly outside the United States for improvement in immunologic function. This treatment also ameliorates the JH phase of anti infective therapy. It is further noticed that direct exposure to sunlight has a similar effect to UBI in many patients. Therefore my patients are asked to get sun exposure if the climate allow s not using sunscreen up to the point of mild burning. I caution them that minocycline will cause them to be sensitive, but that they can go out with care and receive great benefit. And as I had expected, I do see stable patients develop mild JH re actions after such activities as fishing trips which cause a huge UV sun dose and large destruction of circulating bacteria.
Another approach to treating worsening of symptoms after oral antibiotic or other anti-infective therapy is the use of IV a ntibiotics. I have used IV doxycycline for quelling such problems. Other physicians have used IV minocycline, IV clindamycin and others for this purpose. In my practice the antibiotics are the drugs of last resort. The most preferred treatments involve the home remedies with peroxide and vitamin C.
I have tried to avoid the use of anti-inflammatory remedies for the JH reaction. The corticosteroids will control a rash, but I have noted a general deterioration of the patient's condition weeks later. Such topical steroids as are given in inhaled or skin medications are certainly absorbed. Their use will be a quick fix at a high cost due to the setback they cause. The nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories that are used orally have the effect of irritating t he GI system and are implicated as one of the causes of the leaky gut syndrome also linked to many of the chronic pain states. Again they are drugs of a last resort. Topical soothing lotions such as aloe vera can do no harm and may make a rash feel better.
Yeast overgrowth must be considered when new symptoms develop after antibiotics are started. I put all chronic pain patients on continuous oral acidophilus supplements before starting any anti-infective therapy. We were noticing yeast emergence i n nearly 100% of the patients. With the addition of acidophilus, this problem is becoming a lot less common.
Summary
Worsening or flaring of symptoms after the commencement of anti-infective therapy should be expected and considered a JH reaction. The patient should be cautioned about the signs of a potentially life threatening anaphilactoid reaction and urged to seek medical attention at once. The more common clinical non-life threatening flares should not cause undo concern to the patient and may be treated by altering the medication dosage and with some of the suggested therapies above. Abandoning of the anti-infective approach to chronic pain and arthritic disease would be unfortunate simply because of these expected temporary setbacks.
-------------------- There is no wealth but life. -John Ruskin
All truth goes through 3 stages: first it is ridiculed: then it is violently opposed: finally it is accepted as self evident. - Schopenhauer Posts: 5639 | From Aptos CA USA | Registered: Apr 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
Very interesting, Sarah, thanks for posting it.
It explains why I generally get really ill if I go out into the sun for more than a few minutes ... I also now think it's very significant that I was out in the sun for a couple hours today (I felt good today) and did NOT get sick! YAY! I always thought there was some connection between sunlight and herxing ... everyone says it's the heat, but I don't get the same reaction from my FIR sauna.
-------------------- sixgoofykids.blogspot.com Posts: 13449 | From Ohio | Registered: Feb 2007
| IP: Logged |
This is a good article. Most of us know about this bodily, but to have a succinct article validating what we've experienced is a godsend.
Guess you are the angel behind the godsend...
Thanks a third time,
Best O'Best,
wiserforit
Posts: 508 | From Banks of the Hudson | Registered: Jul 2006
| IP: Logged |
treepatrol
Honored Contributor (10K+ posts)
Member # 4117
posted
Going to add to Newbies links.
Treating the Jarisch-Herxheimer (JH) Flare Reaction
Stuart L. Weg, M.D. is certified by the American Board of Anesthesiology with added qualifications in pain management.
The observed temporary worsening of clinical status in patients undergoing anti-infective treatment is called the Jarisch-Herxheimer (JH) reaction.
It may be referred to by some of the terms listed below. This phenomenon, described in the cover article, is not just present in rheumatologic disease but is common to all forms of anti-infective therapies that I have used for most chronic painful states.
This apparent common etiology of all chronic pain and arthritis is not within the scope of this discussion but will be covered in the future.
The JH reaction can take the mild form of sleepiness and fatigue to full blown anaphylactic shock. The timing varies from almost immediately, as is the case of IV antibiotics, to up to a week or two later.
This depends on the rate that toxins are produced and how fast they can be metabolized or eliminated. Drug levels are important, but often cannot explain the timin g of a reaction.
In some cases an overwhelming, waterfall effect is present, while in other patients there is a slow, gradual building of symptoms.
I have seen cases where adding another unrelated medication caused the antibiotic to become more bioavailable and that precipitated a JH.
There are cases where simply changing a single 100 mg daily dose of minocycline to two 50 mg split doses has provoked a JH due to an absorption increase.
Reducing, suspending or changing the offending medication is the most obvious treatment. ???maybe
Patients must understand that early signs of the JH reaction may not be present; even the most conscientious and observant physicians may not stop or lower the medication in time to avoid patient discomfort.
The classical discuss ions of a JH describe the presence of bacterial debris or toxins from anti-infective therapies that cause this reaction. This is certainly true, but another byproduct is also formed when cell wall deficient bacteria or L forms are attacked.
I have noticed that some JH present as a flu syndrome. Other patients develop purulent drainage from the head and neck, urine and other areas.
When I have cultured these patients, I have been able to isolate adult (non L-form) bacteria. Treatment with medications that favor the destruction of L-forms who are unwalled forms will also favor or select for the survival of adult or walled forms of bacteria.
1 Microbiologists call this change of the form of bacteria pleomorphism. The induction of walled forms of bacteria has been studied and should be kept in mind when considering treating a JH reaction.
Treatment of a JH should be aimed at eliminating toxins from the killed bacteria and destruction of newly induced adult b acteria. Consideration should also be given to the possibility of overgrowth of endemic yeast infections.
Often there are symptoms that clinically indicate the presence of histamine. The physician's diagnostic skills and clinical judgment must be called into place to differentiate between a direct toxic reaction versus the appearance of an adult form organism or the more insidious development of yeast overgrowth.
For the ease of the reader, I am classifying the JH reaction into two categories:
1) Acute - life-threatening. These may also be called anaphilactoid.
2) Non-acute or non-life-threatening- not anaphilactoid.
Acute - Life Threatening
The severe acute reactions are probably related to a massive response of the immune system to toxins. There may be a large release of histamine as well.
Such anaphilactoid reactions need immediate attention and should be considered life-threatening. The most severe problems involve swelling of the neck areas and closure of the airway.
This must be treated at once with epinephrine followed by transportation to a hospital. The management of severe anaphilactoid emergencies is well known by healthcare personnel and beyond the ability of the patients to handle at home.
A drop in blood pressure is also common along with skin changes due to dilation of the blood vessels. This can lead to cardiovascular collapse unless aggressively treated and also needs hospital management.
Milder cases featuring asthma may respond to inhaled broncodialator medications, but this can sometimes delay the patient from seeking early medical attention and avoiding catastrophe. Skin rashes are not life threatening but often are quite distressing. A more detailed
Anti-infective therapies or approaches that can feature the JH
Antibiotic/antifungal therapies < LI>Oxidative therapies Ozone Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation Hydrogen Peroxide therapy High dose vitamin C therapy Induced Hyperthermia Sunlight exposure Various herbal therapies Bee sting reactions Iodine reacti ons Terms in Use for JH
Herxheimer Reaction Die Off Reaction Flare Reaction Coming Out Reaction Summary of Tre atment Features of Life Threatening JH Reactions
Treatment of histaminic states Acute life threatening histamine shock or airway swelling Epinephrine with fluids for shock Mild JH Reactions
Anti-histamine medication e.g.benadryl parenterally or by mouth Supportive Care for Anaphylactic Type JH Reactions
Management of Bronchospasm (acute asthma) with Bronchodialators discussion of these kinds of problems is presented in most textbooks of medicine and all manuals for emergency care.
Management of Non-life Threat ening JH Reactions or Clinical Flares
The more typical JH reactions to anti-infective therapies are: worsening of symptoms, febrile states such as night sweats, flu-like picture, hot swollen joints, mental depression and fatigue.
I recommend home therapies designed to clear the blood and make the patient more comfortable. My routine calls for baths in hydrogen peroxide and Epsom salts.
These baths are very effective and have tremendous anti-infective effects. They may work for only a short time at first and may need to be repeated.
The peroxide easily enters the body through the skin and rapidly detoxifies and sterilizes the blood. There will be a marked reduction in tight muscles that can be a part of a JH reaction.
Unfortunately peroxide can have a JH reaction of its own, but this is more pronounced when it is used IV rather than in a bath. Magnesium in the Epsom salts also passes easily systematically; it has a local anesthetic, antispasmodic effect and an overall improvement in the performance of most systems.
Oral peroxide is available but not discussed here. The IV route for both peroxide and magnesium is used to stop the JH reaction in office management.
The same benefit of blood detoxification and general enhanced clearing of tissue toxins and bacteria can be claimed for high dose ascorbic acid (20-50 GMs IV).
Vitamin C can be given in oral form too. Ascorbic acid powder equals about 5 grams per level teaspoon. This dose can be taken with water or juice as often as needed or until there is GI intolerance such as diarrhea.
The clinical effects are similar to peroxide. In fact, the two can be given to a patient on the same day with excellent results.
It must be remembered however; the vitamin C will also neutralize peroxide and thus should always be given after the bath.
Mild JH reactions are also seen with vitamin C therapy again mainly when given IV. Such therapies as peroxide baths and vitamin C are easy to do at home and extremely effective at helping patients make a quick, safe recovery from a JH reaction.
Other oxidative office therapies can be alternated with these modalities or with antibiotics to hasten detoxification of bacterial toxins.
Ultraviolet blood irradiation (UBI) involves removing a small portion of the circulating blood and cleaning it under UV light before returning it to the patient.
The mechanism of action is not well known, but such treatment has been used for over fifty years mostly outside the United States for improvement in immunologic function.
This treatment also ameliorates the JH phase of anti infective therapy. It is further noticed that direct exposure to sunlight has a similar effect to UBI in many patients.
Therefore my patients are asked to get sun exposure if the climate allow s not using sunscreen up to the point of mild burning. I caution them that minocycline will cause them to be sensitive, but that they can go out with care and receive great benefit.
And as I had expected, I do see stable patients develop mild JH re actions after such activities as fishing trips which cause a huge UV sun dose and large destruction of circulating bacteria.
Another approach to treating worsening of symptoms after oral antibiotic or other anti-infective therapy is the use of IV a ntibiotics. I have used IV doxycycline for quelling such problems.
Other physicians have used IV minocycline, IV clindamycin and others for this purpose. In my practice the antibiotics are the drugs of last resort. The most preferred treatments involve the home remedies with peroxide and vitamin C.
I have tried to avoid the use of anti-inflammatory remedies for the JH reaction. The corticosteroids will control a rash, but I have noted a general deterioration of the patient's condition weeks later.
Such topical steroids as are given in inhaled or skin medications are certainly absorbed. Their use will be a quick fix at a high cost due to the setback they cause.
The nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories that are used orally have the effect of irritating t he GI system and are implicated as one of the causes of the leaky gut syndrome also linked to many of the chronic pain states.
Again they are drugs of a last resort. Topical soothing lotions such as aloe vera can do no harm and may make a rash feel better.
Yeast overgrowth must be considered when new symptoms develop after antibiotics are started.
I put all chronic pain patients on continuous oral acidophilus supplements before starting any anti-infective therapy. We were noticing yeast emergence in nearly 100% of the patients. With the addition of acidophilus, this problem is becoming a lot less common.
Summary
Worsening or flaring of symptoms after the commencement of anti-infective therapy should be expected and considered a JH reaction.
The patient should be cautioned about the signs of a potentially life threatening anaphilactoid reaction and urged to seek medical attention at once.
The more common clinical non-life threatening flares should not cause undo concern to the patient and may be treated by altering the medication dosage and with some of the suggested therapies above.
Abandoning of the anti-infective approach to chronic pain and arthritic disease would be unfortunate simply because of these expected temporary setbacks.
-------------------- Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Remember Iam not a Doctor Just someone struggling like you with Tick Borne Diseases.
How much Peroxide is used in a bath with epsom salt?
I worked as an RN in an office administering IV peroxide and IV Vitamin C drips. I wonder if it would be a good idea to receive these drips as treatment for the herx reactions instead of backing off or stopping meds, so I could progress with treatment?
posted
IV peroxide is controversial and some doctors have been sanctioned for using it, like the one in SC who was on 60 minutes.
Posts: 8430 | From Not available | Registered: Oct 2000
| IP: Logged |
cantgiveupyet
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 8165
posted
Thanks for posting.
I found the information about yeast interesting. That is what happend to me with the abx, new symptoms developed, my current symptoms rarely worsened....i was told it was a herx, but looking back i think it was yeast.
-------------------- "Say it straight simple and with a smile."
"Thus the task is, not so much to see what no one has seen yet, But to think what nobody has thought yet, About what everybody sees."
-Schopenhauer
pos babs, bart, igenex WB igm/igg Posts: 3156 | From Lyme limbo | Registered: Oct 2005
| IP: Logged |
bettyg
Unregistered
posted
Tree, God bless you for breaking this up for us neuro lymies and adding it to your links.
The Lyme Disease Network is a non-profit organization funded by individual donations. If you would like to support the Network and the LymeNet system of Web services, please send your donations to:
The
Lyme Disease Network of New Jersey 907 Pebble Creek Court,
Pennington,
NJ08534USA http://www.lymenet.org/
UBBFriend: Email this page to someone!
![[group hug]](graemlins/grouphug.gif)
![[kiss]](graemlins/kissing.gif)
Printer-friendly view of this topic