Topic: Is the General Medical Population Biased against Women?
cafe67
Unregistered
posted
My husband and I saw the same GP. Myself, first after 8 months of on going symptoms. GP diagnosed me as anxiety/depression prescribed anti-depressant. I finally, through much research and much help from here, figured out it is lyme and am now being treated by a great LLMD.
My husband, after recently starting with the same symptoms, went to our GP. My Hubby presented to him with the EXACT same symptoms as me. Joint aches, major fatigue, heart palps, tight/squeezing chest, shortness of breath, dry cough, etc.
The GP, even after knowing my history, diagnosed him with pleurisy. Chest x-ray everything ok! Perfect specimin, if I do say so myself!
1. He did however get doxy - I think the GP is catching on. Along with an inhaler and prednisone, which now I KNOW he should not take.
2. I think maybe I focused more on heart palps and hubby focused more on chest pains? And the doctor took that cue?
3. In a way this might be good that I was the "depressed" one first because my H could have been on prednisone and getting worse.
Not only are we fighting against proper treatment for lyme, but as women, against the pre-disposed opinions of the medical world, who want to fit us neatly into the mental health category; depression.
posted
Cave: I know! LOL I have had several answers in my posts which don't make sense, then I realize that someone has replied to you by mistake. Keeps me laughing anyway, you bunch of lymebrains.
IP: Logged |
posted
I, too think the med profession is biased against women.
Though I tend to see it even with my children - the boy may have the same symptoms as the girl and the boy gets much more of a work up than the girl. Hers are somatic or she is copying her mom.
dontlikeliver
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 4749
posted
Yes. And, it's not just the medical profession. Let me not even get started on that one!
DLL
Posts: 2824 | From The Back of Beyond | Registered: Oct 2003
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
I think it has always been this way, from the earliest of times. It is nothing new. It is basically treating women as children who cannot make their own decisions.
When my parents divorced in the early 70's my mother wanted a tubal ligation. She couldnt get one without my dad's permission (they were not married) OR a male neighbor/friend. So our next door neighbor "gave" his permission.
janet thomas
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 7122
posted
Has a Western Blot been ordered for your husband?? Hugs. Janet
Posts: 2001 | From NJ | Registered: Mar 2005
| IP: Logged |
cafe67
Unregistered
posted
JH - I'm sure our GP did your favorite ELISA test. That's ok, I want him to see how bad they are - we get Hubby an Igenex test at our LLMD next week.
Kara: Funny, not! I am the one who researched all this and made all the mistakes; dealt with drs., etc. Pay and organize all the medical bills to those doctors.
My husbands like "erlicky what" "babooneoisis what"? I basically have to tell him how to go about getting treated - which he is happy to relinquish to me.
Doctors should take better care of the "caregivers of the world"
Well, gotta run I have to do laundry, pay bills, make dinner, get basketball uniform ready for oldest son, pack things to keep others happy at BB game, pack medicine that hubby forgot...............
NP40
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6711
posted
Of course they treat men and women differently ! Why not ? Us men, when we go to the doc, we're really sick !
Seriously, ladies and germs, women are much more in tune with their own bodies. Probably stems from hauling the little papooses around for 9 months.
Men, on the other hand................would sever their leg in a chainsaw accident, and grudgingly go to get a couple of stitches to fix er' up............and then would fantasize about doing the female paramedic on the way to the hospital.
What can I say, we're nutso ! I think the old stereotype holds, that men only go as a last resort, if they can't "shake it". Sooooo, they must "really" be sick ! We are.
Psychologically.
Women of course, will go at the drop of a hat, because they go in the early stages, before they sever all the way through with the chainsaw...........and of course they want to check out the doc to see if he's "marrying" material, for their daughters.
Posts: 1632 | From Northern Wisconsin | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
It's bias based on fear of womens understanding and the ability to self diagnose themselves and family far earlier than any school/med education could teach a doc. Everybody's threatened.
Societally (sp)?:
A woman is always expecting that she needs to be better than she may be, so physically understand when they dont feel well and know/care enough to do something about it.
A man thinks he's pretty good already and doesn't aspire to be any better. When they feel sick, then their life is over, they're dying... wah, wah, wah.
I also feel that the man can't accept the female partner's weakness. It's like driving a used car with square tires. They want you to be there to take care of them like mom used to.
Guys... I AM Generalizing. I have a great husband, but I have dealt with this for so long I would have been better off explaining to him that I had terminal cancer.
Linda LD
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6663
posted
I read about a study and who knows it might have been in the Enquirer--but the article said that a study was published and they sent so many actresses and actors of the same general age to the same emergency rooms describing the same pains. 90% of the men were diagnosed correctly with a heart attack. 90% of the women were told to go home--they had emotional problems.
Wish I could remember where I read this...
l
Posts: 1171 | From Knoxville, TN US | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
I think it is just that men dont want to know what is wrong with them.
Posts: 6022 | From Mobile, AL | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
posted
And statistics say women live at an average of 10 years longer then men also.... so...DUH...tell ya anything, guys??????
Just goes to show...You guys shouldn't just try to "tough it out", that isn't always the smartest thing to do....but then again...that brings us back to the fact that...(what cave76 added)...They also would probably get lost on the way to the hospital because "they wouldn't ask for directions". !
[This message has been edited by laserred (edited 09 June 2005).]
Posts: 493 | From MidWest NorthWoods | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
It would be interesting to do a survey just between men and women, "if you had terminal cancer, would you want to know?"
I want to know what is wrong with me. No matter what!
Aniek
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5374
posted
I can't help but wonder how much of this goes back to old traditions of midwives and women taking care of their family through folk remedies. The doctors needed to believe the women were wrong in order to convince people that a doctor was needed. And, back then, all doctors were men.
For so many years, medical research was also done primarily on white men. That means that doctors simply know more about the male body and the impact of drugs on the male body. And, it's even limited by race.
Posts: 4711 | From Washington, DC | Registered: Mar 2004
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
Unfort. the 1960's insisted that men and women were the same (and that all races were the same)medically. Neither is true.
Women react differant to medications, so do people of differant races.
There is much research that shows that people do better with blood transfusions from others of the same race (if possible). But heaven forbid that we consider this fact.
posted
I agree that women definitely get the short end of the stick as patients, just like they do in most (not all) other spheres of life. Also, the Steere camp is mainly men - some of them very viciously sexist, like Sigal and Shapiro.
Here is an excellent new article just out, dealing with medical misogyny, by ILADS Dr Virginia Sherr:
Med Hypotheses. 2005 May 27; [Epub ahead of print] Related Articles, Links
Munchausen's syndrome by proxy and Lyme disease: Medical misogyny or diagnostic mystery?
Sherr VT.
47 Crescent Drive, Holland, PA 18966-2105, USA.
Chronic, tertiary Lyme disease, a vector-borne infection most accurately designated neuroborreliosis, is often misdiagnosed.
Infectors of the human brain, Lyme borrelial spirochetes are neurotropic, similar to the spirochetes of syphilis. Symptoms of either disease may be stable and persistent, transient and inconsistent or severe yet fleeting.
Characteristics may be incompatible with established knowledge of neurological dermatomes, appearing to conventional medical eyes as anatomically impossible, thus creating confusion for doctors, parents and child patients.
Physicians unfamiliar with Lyme patients' shifting, seemingly vague, emotional, and/or bizarre-sounding complaints, frequently know little about late-stage spirochetal disease. Consequently, they may accuse mothers of fabricating their children's symptoms - the so-called Munchausen's by proxy (MBP) "diagnoses."
Women, following ancient losses of feminine authority in provinces of religion, ethics, and healing - disciplines comprising known fields of early medicine, have been scapegoated throughout history. In the Middle Ages, women considered potentially weak-minded devil's apprentices became victims of witch-hunts throughout Europe and America. Millions of women were burned alive at the stake.
Modern medicine's tendency to trivialize women's "offbeat" concerns and the fact that today's hurried physicians of both genders tend to seek easy panaceas, frequently result in the misogyny of mother-devaluation, especially by doctors who are spirochetally naive. These factors, when involving cases of cryptic neuroborreliosis, may lead to accusations of MBP.
Thousands of children, sick from complex diseases, have been forcibly removed from mothers who insist, contrary to customary evaluations, that their children are ill.
The charges against these mothers relate to the idea they believe their children sick to satisfy warped internal agendas of their own. "MBP mothers" are then vilified, frequently jailed and publicly shamed for the "sins" of advocating for their children.
In actuality, many such cases involve an unrecognized Lyme borreliosis causation that mothers may insist is valid despite negative tests.
Doctors who have utilized MBP tactics against mothers are likely to be unaware that in advanced borreliosis, seronegativity is often the rule, a principle disagreed upon by its two extant, published, peer-reviewed, Standards of Care. These are guidelines for Lyme disease management - the older system questioning the existence of persistent Lyme and the newer system relying on established clinical criteria.
Mothers must be free to obtain the family's preferred medical care by choosing between physicians practicing within either system without fear of reprisal. Doctors and mothers together may then explore medical options with renewed mutual respect toward the best interest of children's health.
PMID: 15925450 [PubMed - as supplied by publisher]
[This message has been edited by Lymerayja (edited 10 June 2005).]
JillF
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5553
posted
My LLMD makes my weight an issue every time I see him.
He wants me to see a nutritionist he works with.
My husband needs to lose at least as much weight as me.
The same LLMD will not bring up my husband's weight at all. Does not tell him to lose weight, does not ask him if he's lost any weight, does not tell him that he needs to see the nutritionist...
I am not amused at all that this LLMD is making my weight a big deal but won't even mention my husband's weight at all.
posted
Is the medical profession biased against women?
Why, OF COURSE IT IS, darling!
hahahahaha!
I know it's not really a laughing matter, but I'd rather laugh hysterically and inappropriately than to cry - because if I CRY -that just means my hormones are messed up because I'm an overly-sensitive WOMAN! Gag)
The only time I generally have penis envy is when I see a doc for the first time, and right after Thanksgiving dinner when the 'boys' retire in front of the TV with their hands down their pants - and the 'women' get to clean up!
------------------ DR. Wiseass - not a real doc - just a real wise ass. www.twistoflyme.blogspot.com
Carol in PA
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 5338
posted
The answer to your question is, "Heck yes!"
When I had five teeth surgically removed, the dentist told me to take Tylenol for the pain. Several years later, my husband went to the SAME oral surgeon to have wisdom teeth removed, and the doc gave him a prescription for narcotics for pain relief. Sheesh.....
Carol
Posts: 6947 | From Lancaster, PA | Registered: Feb 2004
| IP: Logged |
The Lyme Disease Network is a non-profit organization funded by individual donations. If you would like to support the Network and the LymeNet system of Web services, please send your donations to:
The
Lyme Disease Network of New Jersey 907 Pebble Creek Court,
Pennington,
NJ08534USA http://www.lymenet.org/