I believe Butalbital is Fioricet plus caffeine plus aspirin..I'll check. Drugs similar to Fioricet did not help my daughter either. Codeine helped only slightly.The chiropractor and physical therapist documented for me recently their opinions that although my daughter has considerable muscle tension in her neck, this is not the cause of her headache and may even be the other way around: partly a result of her headache pain, which would then cause muscles to tighten.
Personally, I think neck muscle tension contributes to the head pain, which then contributes to the neck pain, in a viscious cycle. I wanted them to work on the muscles, but they said chiro/PT were not helping her at all and that the head pain was from some "internal process" which is unknown.
Lyme causes muscle tightness and pain for us, naturally. The LLMD also attributes the head pain to Lyme encephalopathy (sp?).
The pain specialist said that some injury to the brain (not meaning trauma, but broadly covering everything from trauma to infection) could set off a situation where the brain cells interpret sensations in such a way that pain is amplified. I bristle a little at this, but he assured me this was not a fancy way of saying it was psychologoical, but a truly physical phenomenon.
The reason I asked for documentation was that a diagnosis of head pain from muscle tension is interpreted by many MD's as being psychological or emotional in origin. In the absence of positive MRI, MRA or EEG, we were starting to hear that my daughter should see a psychiatrist.
I have taken her to two psych. providers recently and they have both given her a clean bill of mental health.
This is great, but her head still hurts. Since Jan. 6th, 2003. Your son has had pain much longer than that, and I hope he gets some relief soon. A child with a 10+ headache isn't too easy for a mom to bear, either, so my thoughts are with you.