Nancy, this is in the "for what it's worth" category.First of all -- a sane and healthy person would find these decisions difficult and frightening. On top of that you have an illness that fries your brain and causes fear and indecisiveness all by itself. Don't feel like a schmuck; you're in a horrid situation and 99% of the "experts" with years of medical training don't know how to handle it, either.
I've done extremely well on the right abx combo. But it was years and years and years of being an unwilling guineapig (and waiting for the new research) before I found an LLMD who knew what to do for me. There were times on abx when I sat up all night in the rocking chair feeling my heart go haywire and waiting to die (at that point, it couldn't be soon enough as far as I was concerned). I had major stomach miseries, severe vertigo and dizziness, etc. etc.
I consider myself extremely lucky in finding the right LLMD and in not sustaining any permanent damage from the abx (so far, anyway).
I'm also lucky in that many of the "alternative" tx I've done recently have been very successful for me. I spent 6 mo. on freeze-dried garlic as part of Dr. Zhang's protocol (no abx during that time). The rest of his stuff helped only marginally, but the garlic did terrific things for the yeast, my stomach and my intestines and, I think, helped my system recover in general. I don't recall much of a herx on the garlic, other than the original yeast die off.
The portable sauna was cheap and I think it's helped a great deal. I've been doing it daily along with abx and detox. I've seen significant improvements that I attribute to all 3.
I herxed painfully on samento at first, and on artemesinin. When it comes to herxing (rather than bad reactions to the med itself), I haven't found that the herbal stuff is much easier on me than most abx.
My experiences of non-treatment (abx or otherwise) were very bad -- usually a short lull of a couple of months, then a plunge into full relapse. I really, really don't think doing nothing is an option.
If you feel that your LLMD is well informed, responsive and aware, can you try his system for a set period of time and see how it goes? Knowing that you'll probably feel a lot worse for several months before you start seeing any kind of improvement? And knowing that if this doesn't work for you, there are alternatives you can go to?
Part of what I'm thinking is that if you can get to a point of some improvement, with less anxiety and brainfog, you'll be in a position to rethink things if need be, and choose a different treatment if you need to.
You're probably doing this already, but I've found a daily record of what was going on with me (strictly symptomatic, not a real diary) helped greatly when it came to evaluating treatment. This past year, even when things didn't seem to be going well, I could count up the number of good vs. bad days, and I could see that I was inching towards recovery.
Sorry to be so wordy. I can't seem to find a compact way to say anything recently. But I wanted to respond because I'm worried that, with the more effective abx treatments for coinfections etc., people who have difficulty tolerating abx are being sidelined out of the treatment loop. And we need good treatment for ALL of us.
Good luck. Let us know how you go on.