This is topic Is the Culligan water softener system bad for drinki in forum Medical Questions at LymeNet Flash.

To visit this topic, use this URL:

Posted by nefferdun (Member # 20157) on :
They did not bypass our drinking water. Since they installed it my husband and I have had digestive disturbances. I just filled out a questionaire for a new LLMD and one of the questions was if we had the culligan softener. That got me to thinking and wondering.
Posted by Razzle (Member # 30398) on :
Water softeners use high sodium to "soften" the water, so your water is likely very high in sodium. This will change the balance of gut bugs (or maybe even kill some of them off).

I don't know what, if anything, else is added during water softening.

Also, if they installed a granular carbon water filter, those have a tendency to grow bad bacteria in the filter, which then can infect the drinking water.
Posted by sixgoofykids (Member # 11141) on :
We didn't have the bypass put on our system (which is not culligan, but a different brand softener) because the RO filtration works better on soft water. So you might get an RO filter for your water, then it won't matter that it's soft.

I've always heard you're not supposed to drink soft water.
Posted by nefferdun (Member # 20157) on :
Thanks so much. No wonder we have been having all the bloating and gas. I will get bottled water until I can get it fixed or removed.
Posted by Deb133 (Member # 18544) on :
My husband has been selling/installing water treatment equipment for thirty years. Let me just give you a few facts:

1. The drinking water is not normally bypassed.

2. For every grain of hardness removed you are
adding 17.1 mg/liter of sodium. So depending
on the amount of hardness you have determines
how much sodium is added to the water.

3. There is nothing else added to soften water.

4. Carbon can aid in the growth of bacteria but
unless you have the bacteria in your water to
begin with carbon doesn't produce bacteria on
its own.

5. Yes the RO will work better with soft water.
ROs were designed to produce drinking water
from sea water so they will easily remove
the small amount of salt added by the

Hope this helps answer any questions or concerns.

Posted by Deb133 (Member # 18544) on :
If anyone has any questions at all about treating your water, equipment etc please do not
hesitate to ask.

Posted by nefferdun (Member # 20157) on :
Thanks Deb, the person who did the test said our water was extremely hard. I have had a fever for two days so I think what I have been experiencing is something unrelated to the water. The bloating and gas went away - knock on wood.
Posted by Deb133 (Member # 18544) on :
Glad your feeling better. If you ever need any info or have any questions send me a PM.

Good luck,


Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3