By PAM BELLUCK The New York Times - Published: September 6, 2009
NANTUCKET, Mass. -- In the annals of animals linked to human disease, there is surely a place for Old Buck of Nantucket.
Spotted in 1922 deer-paddling in the ocean, he was scooped up by a fishing sloop and brought to Nantucket, an island then without a single deer. And since the animal, nicknamed Old Buck, was single, Nantucket took pity on him. With help from a summer resident, a diplomat who had helped create the League of Nations, two does were imported from Michigan in 1926, greeted at the wharf by a cheering crowd.
Nantucket became so sweet on its deer that when Old Buck was killed by a car in 1932, a newspaper editorialized: "He deserved to live to a good old age, that he might see his grandchildren, great-grandchildren, great-great-grandchildren, and a lot more grand progeny, thrive happily in the swamps and moors of Nantucket."
Now that progeny, island-bound with no apparent swimmers among them, is the focus of Nantucket's attempt to grapple with diseases caused by ticks that feed on deer blood. Not just the familiar Lyme disease but also babesiosis and ehrlichiosis, which are less common, can be debilitating or fatal.
Last year, Nantucket had 411 laboratory-confirmed cases of tick diseases, up from 257 in 2007. And health officials say some cases are not reported, some Lyme disease diagnoses are made clinically, and some visitors' ailments are diagnosed off-island.
"We recognize that it's a big problem here," said Michael Kopko, chairman of the Nantucket Board of Selectmen, whose wife and daughter have had tick illnesses. "Those of us who live here all know someone or are related to someone or have ourselves had a tick-borne disease."
After prodding from summer residents, Kopko said, the town appointed a committee, which will make recommendations this fall. It is looking at options including trimming brush in backyards and installing feeders that spray deer with insecticide.
Most controversial is whether to allow more deer-hunting.
"The numbers of tick-borne diseases are so off the graph, and it all comes back to the deer," said Richard Ray, Nantucket's health department director. Some tick experts believe that island-dwellers may more frequently encounter ticks co-infected with two or all three diseases. That could be because high numbers of ticks increase the odds of being bitten by co-infected ones or because the ticks' concentrated food supply increases their co-infection risk.
Michael Miller, a 52-year-old martial arts instructor, contracted Lyme disease and babesiosis simultaneously and was so weakened and feverish that doctors initially thought he had malaria or tuberculosis.
"In a place like Nantucket or any other island, there's less biodiversity, which can mean more intense transmission of infections," said Dr. Sam Telford III, a tick expert at Tufts University's school of veterinary medicine.
Houses built closer to deer habitat draw deer to tasty landscaping, and that brings ticks closer to people. Officials estimate that there are about 2,500 deer, about 60 per square mile -- compared with 10 to 20 per square mile on the mainland.
Measuring the problem is difficult. Reporting criteria for tick diseases has changed and per capita disease rates are inexact because Nantucket's population swings from about 10,000 off-season to about 40,000 in summer, and because cases contracted on-island but diagnosed elsewhere are often not reported here. Numbers fluctuate for other reasons -- this year, for example, authorities expect fewer cases, saying tourism was down and rain kept people inside.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has listed Nantucket among the top three Lyme disease counties since 1992.
In a recent survey of about 220 homeowners in Nantucket's Tom Nevers section, 61 percent said one or more household members, including guests and renters, have had a tick disease.
"We see the tip of the iceberg, the people who get sick," Dr. Timothy Lepore, Nantucket's surgeon and tick expert, told the committee. "These diseases, while not necessarily the four horsemen of the apocalypse, have caused near-fatalities."
Tom Foley, 54, a summer resident, contracted babesiosis recently, which lacerated his spleen. He was one of many people who had to be airlifted off Nantucket for treatment because its hospital would be overstretched. "People are going to die from this," Foley said. "People don't want to talk about it -- they're worried it will hurt property values -- but something has to be done."
Laura Mueller, 73, a 40-year summer resident, barely survived babesiosis in 2007.
"I'm dying," she kept telling doctors. Her condition proved too dire for airlifting; Lepore removed her ruptured spleen, exhausting most of the hospital's blood supply. Her recovery took 10 months.
As the island considers solutions, the "February hunt" of 2005 looms large.
An extra hunting week, added because few other states have deer-hunting then, attracted hundreds of hunters from as far as Florida and Texas. But Nantucket was blasted with 3 feet of snow, and hunters unfamiliar with the terrain could not get to the moors.
"They were showing up in bright orange where there were occupied houses, and people were going bananas thinking they were going to shoot," said Jim Lentowski, executive director of the Nantucket Conservation Foundation. A preschool even closed.
In the end, 246 deer were killed, far exceeding scientists' expectations of 100.
"From our point of view it was great," said Rob Deblinger, deputy director of the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife. "But from some other points of view it was horrible."
After a public outcry, the extra hunt was canceled. Nobody advocates a February hunt again, and the committee will probably recommend several strategies, including public education and Damminix, which kills baby ticks feeding on the mice carrying the initial tick-disease bacteria.
Laura Simon, a wildlife ecologist for the Humane Society of the United States, told the committee that "killing deer will not work" because ticks would feed on other animals.
But several experts told the committee that more hunting is necessary, saying other methods, while potentially helpful, were insufficient and expensive.
"I think there are a lot more people who want to reduce deer numbers than want to snuggle with them," said one committee member, Dr. Tristram Dammin, son of the scientist for whom a deer tick, Ixodes dammini, was named.
But Beverly McLaughlin, another committee member, said: "I really love the deer, and I can't help it. My mother took me to see 'Bambi' when I was little."
Although her husband had Lyme disease and babesiosis, she said that even if Nantucket had 400 cases last year, "you know what? That's not an epidemic."
A hunter on the committee, Kevin Madden, said many hunters wanted only modest increases in hunting, so that bagging deer would remain easy. "I don't want to see all the deer wiped out because some people get Lyme's disease," he said. "Let them live until I need them."
------------------------------------------ comment - 400 cases a year reported, how many actual cases were there?
Posts: 8430 | From Not available | Registered: Oct 2000
| IP: Logged |
bettyg
Unregistered
posted
thx lou for the post...lengthy one!
the last paragraph TICKS ME OFF ROYALLY!!
i see comments are asked for!! i'll see about creating one...
edited: lou, do you have the link and can post at the top of your post? big thanks my friend..
IP: Logged |
posted
Sorry, Betty, this came up in a google automatic search and I deleted the email after posting the article. I quit posting urls for news articles because most of the time it is only available at the url address for a short time, then you get a page not found message.
However, this one is in the NY Times so if you really want to comment, can find it there. I didn't comment because a lot of people read this paper and will probably do it for us.
The NY Times has been nearly a total bust in the lyme story, so this is out of character. But they gave the last word to people who say this is not an epidemic. Well if three quarters of the population are summer people, it is not likely that the number of reported cases is anywhere near reflective of the true number. And how many of those people get diagnosed after they leave the island?
Posts: 8430 | From Not available | Registered: Oct 2000
| IP: Logged |
TF
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 14183
posted
400 cases a year sounds like an epidemic to me. That's 400+ ruined lives per year.
-------------------- --Lymetutu-- Opinions, not medical advice! Posts: 96239 | From Texas | Registered: Feb 2001
| IP: Logged |
bettyg
Unregistered
posted
more info on writing letter to editor for feedback on above article ....
Letters to the Editor
Letters to the editor should only be sent to The Times, and not to other publications. We do not publish open letters or third-party letters.
Letters for publication should be no longer than 150 words, must refer to an article that has appeared within the last seven days, and must include the writer's address and phone numbers. No attachments, please.
We regret we cannot return or acknowledge unpublished letters.
Writers of those letters selected for publication will be notified within a week. Letters may be shortened for space requirements.
Send a letter to the editor by e-mailing [email protected] or faxing (212)556-3622. *******************************************
You may also mail your letter to:
Letters to the Editor The New York Times 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018
To submit a letter to the City, Long Island, Westchester, New Jersey or Connecticut weekly sections, please e-mail [email protected]..
About Letters
Thomas Feyer, the letters editor, gives tips for getting your letter published. Click here for full article.
Additional Information?
Please call (212) 556-1831 for recorded instructions.
Other article submissions: Send your article to the editor of the department relevant to your piece (e.g. "News Editor," "Sports Editor") via regular mail to the address above.
IP: Logged |
bettyg
Unregistered
posted
my reply....
NANTUCKET BATTLES TICK-BORNE DISEASES feedback:
An epidemic is 2 people in the SAME county having a disease; YES, Lyme and babesiosis ARE epidemic in Nantucket! 400 reported; how many weren't?
"A hunter on the committee, Kevin Madden, said many hunters wanted only modest increases in hunting, so that bagging deer would remain easy. "I don't want to see all the deer wiped out because some people get Lyme's disease," he said. "Let them live until I need them.""
Kevin Madson's comment about not wiping out all dear because SOME people get Lyme disease stinks!
You have no idea how much pain and suffering Lyme and co-infection people go thru plus the decades of being misdiagnosed!
I've had chronic Lyme disease 40 years this Christmas; 34.5 years MISDIAGNOSED by 40-50 drs! UNACCEPTABLE!
IP: Logged |
posted
Interesting article thanks for sharing. 400 cases is not an epidemic? What a ridiculous statement. For more than one reason including the fact that in realty the number is much higher. She's right though it's not a epidemic it's a pandemic it spreads much further than Nantucket or the U.S. for that matter.
-------------------- If you keep doing nothing...nothing changes!
The Lyme Disease Network is a non-profit organization funded by individual donations. If you would like to support the Network and the LymeNet system of Web services, please send your donations to:
The
Lyme Disease Network of New Jersey 907 Pebble Creek Court,
Pennington,
NJ08534USA http://www.lymenet.org/
UBBFriend: Email this page to someone!
![[cussing]](graemlins/cussing.gif)
![[toilet]](graemlins/toilet.gif)
![[tsk]](graemlins/tsk.gif)
![[puke]](graemlins/puke.gif)
Printer-friendly view of this topic