JillF
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5553
posted
I have been looking into ALS and Lyme for a family friend. This guy has had ALS for 10+ years and I don't think he has ever been tested correctly for Lyme.
----------------------------------- QUESTION -- Can ALS be confused with Lyme disease? Is it worth getting tested for Lyme disease? What about taking a course of antibiotics to see what happens?
DR. BRADLEY -- ALS can rarely be confused with Lyme disease, and many patients have taken multiple courses of antibiotics without benefit. Mostly the explanation is that the patient with ALS also had exposure to Lyme disease in the past, not that the infection causes the ALS. ------------------------------------
What do you think? I have found SO MANY different stories, articles and research saying the TOTAL OPPOSITE!!!!!!!!! That LYME is MIS-diagnosed AS ALS all the time.
I truly hope noone read that and decided against getting tested for Lyme.
TheCrimeOfLyme
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 4019
posted
Yes! Yes Yes!
Google ALS and Lyme keywords, there is a whole site dedicated to ALS/Lyme. I am on my work computer and not my home one, or I would send it to you.
Anywho, um I forgot what I way saying.
Just that yes it is possible
OH and ALS ( if it WERE ALS for TEN years? nah, sounds like lyme)
Posts: 3169 | From Greensburg, Pennsylvania | Registered: Jun 2003
| IP: Logged |
rosesisland2000
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 2001
posted
Crime, I was going to say the same thing... www.google.com and use the keywords ALS, Lyme and you'll find all the information you need about ALS as an often diagnosis when it was Lyme all along.
Google has greater resources, many times it's greater than any information found here. But, you can click the search key here and use the keywords, ALS, Lyme and get some great results also.
Posts: 10564 | From PA Where the Creeks are Red | Registered: Jun 2003
| IP: Logged |
Lishs mom
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2344
posted
ALS is very often confused with Lyme disease on the West Coast. In fact, lyme is not considered (or you have "false positives" if it is) and are still diagnosed with ALS...unless you know to advocate for yourself.
In Oregon of 61 CDC positive lyme cases (that I know of), over half of them were initially diagonsed with ALS, and of that half , about 1/4 were diagnosed with either ALS or MS, or both.
So I would think that they are very similar in presentation.
posted
Yes Yes yes....and I say this from first hand experience. My son in law is living in a nursing home because a doctor here in Clearwater Florida thought he knew EVERYTHING and there is NO LYME IN FLORIDA!!! Diagnosed this young man with ALS no cure get your life in order....My son in law demanded a Lyme blood test....guess what after the culture was grown they found he had Lyme. Now had this doctor done his job the correct was - my son in law would have been 3 months ahead of the game and could have started treatment soon than 3 months later and not be in the shape he is in. Lyme minicks ALS, MD MS and other neurological disorders.
There is a wonderful doctor in Springfield Mo who will tell you the same thing....So often Lyme is mis diagnosed as ALS and sometimes its too late
SentByHim
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 3998
posted
HELLO HELLO HELLO ALERT ALERT ALERT
that WAS ME!!!
Duck had the "I'm POSITIVE it's ALS and your sx are progressing so quickly you probally have only two years left, one that will be usefull, so go be with you family and make the most of it. Now we are going to do one last test, a spinal tap to just rule out any fungal things I may have missed, but don't get your hopes up, I have to do this to satisify the insurance before I can give you a definate dx of ALS."
They had already "checked my blood for lyme" using the grand old ELISA test and of course it was negitve so of course I didn't have lyme.
I waited two weeks for the tap to come back beliveing God that I didn't have ALS that is was something that the doc missed. Sure enough part of his tap was a Western Blot for Lyme. It came back very postitive for lyme. He couldn't believe it, said that it wasn't part of his normal protocal and didn't know why the lab added that test.
I know somone was watching over me
I can only immagine what hell I would be in if he would have found leisions that indicated MS, because he was sure that is what it was at first, I would be loaded up on steriods and quite possibly dead by now. I certainly wouldn't be getting better.
Anyhow that is my story on the subject.
Sent
Posts: 1574 | From Port St Lucie, Florida, USA | Registered: May 2003
| IP: Logged |
Nic is also diagnosed with ALS. When you do a search for ALS you will found his story as a post by Martijn.
The 'ducks' still think it is PSMA (a brother of ALS) and not Lyme. They know there can be Lyme in the Netherlands, but they believe in easy cure (max. 30 days abx; no cure = no Lyme). Even our Lyme-specialist (super duck) send somebody home with a differant diagnose after four times positif tested for LD, he said it must be false positif (4x ).
For Nic it doesn't matter anymore. As long as his physician wants to treat him.
Good luck,
Ingeborg and Nic
------------------ It never was so dark, or it will be light again.
Posts: 86 | From Leiden/Noordwijk, the Netherlands | Registered: Jan 2004
| IP: Logged |
Mathias
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5298
SUBJ (11/02): TESTING FOR LYME DISEASE I have heard that amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) motor neuron disease symptoms can be caused by Lyme disease and that the tests for Lyme disease are often false negatives. What type of confirming test can be done to rule Lyme either disease in or out? How should someone proceed with making sure they are getting the most accurate tests and treatments?
REPLY from MDA:
An ALS-like disorder may be mimicked by Lyme infection, but in my experience the two can be differentiated with some laboratory help. ALS can occur in individuals who are infected with the "bug" that causes Lyme disease (borrelia burgdorferi). Lyme disease antibodies may be found in the blood of ALS patients who come from so-called endemic areas where Lyme disease has an increased prevalence in the population (such as the northern United States). ALS patients who have positive Lyme antibodies in their blood have generally not responded favorably to treatment with antibiotics.
In terms of the sensitivity of which test to use for diagnosing Lyme disease, I understand that the Western blot is the most sensitive. However, there are some recent studies to suggest that testing against some specific proteins of the "bug" might be even more sensitive as such testing is usually negative in normal individuals.
The Lyme Disease Network is a non-profit organization funded by individual donations. If you would like to support the Network and the LymeNet system of Web services, please send your donations to:
The
Lyme Disease Network of New Jersey 907 Pebble Creek Court,
Pennington,
NJ08534USA http://www.lymenet.org/