Topic: Daughter's school wants her to go.....Nature
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
I just got a call from my daughter's school about the Nature's Classroom trip that I spoke out against this fall and told my daughter that I didn't want her to attend.
Last year, a kid came back with lyme, and I suffer from it dearly--mcs, breathing problems, autoimmune issues, pancreatitis, seizure--in a nutshell. I just don't want my kids going to places where there is known tick infestation, namely CT or near the oceans.
Now I hear my daughter's greatest wish (this coming from some DARE class) is to go. The DARE rep, a cop, promised me he would keep her out of the woods, let her call me every day, etc.
I told him I couldn't even think about a decision like this now. Trip is next week, and now I am a wreck. How can anyone tell me that she won't get bit. I heard that there are ticks in the cabins, and my daughter has long hair down to her back. Who is conceivably going to check my kid's underwear to see if anything is crawling there?
My husband's sister who is a nature lover, and a teacher thinks it would be good for my daughter to sleep away for a week. I don't mind her sleeping away....I just want to make sure she's not sleeping with ticks. I wanted my husband to take her away for the week.
Now, husband says maybe she should go, and I know I will be a wreck. I can't even relax now.
What to do?
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
MammaLyme
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 1257
posted
Make sure she gets herself sprayed with DEET. My two grandchildren had lyme 12 and 10 year olds. The one had to be treated for 4 years but is now well. They always spray with DEET before going out in any field etc.
Linda LD
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6663
posted
I'm with Mamma Lyme--go with the deet. My four year old came in with two ticks the other day. We can't keep him from living--but we come from outside stock--he wants to go outside. We just need to do a better job of protecting him.
Give her the deet. Tell the councellor she has to bath everyday to get the deet off and that will help with the ticks too. Get her the stuff to spray on her clothes and do that before she goes.
Just some ideas... L
Posts: 1171 | From Knoxville, TN US | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
janet thomas
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 7122
posted
My daughter is 13 and it's a no-win situation to keep her out of tick habitat.
I spray all the shoes in my household with 0.5% permethrin spray, but keep that to myself. I do it when no one is home.
Call around to sporting goods stores, or check online.
I have the same struggle with my husband and daughter, they say -We can't live in a bubble.
lla2
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2364
posted
you have to let her go diane. I know it's scary, but you can't protect her from the woods and grasses forever. cover her up and let her have some fun, with the other kids....
she's got to live a normal life..lyme willl always be there, even when she's 21....I cover my kids everyday, and their off into the pond and hte woods etc...then they check themselves..
Lisa
Posts: 4713 | From saunderstown, ri Usa | Registered: Apr 2002
| IP: Logged |
lymemomtooo
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5396
posted
Di, my heart goes out to you..I let my daughter go on a whale watch trip to New England before we ever had a diagnosis..They did the marsh and the whole go thru the tick habitat thing..
If I had known then that she already had lyme disease, she would not have gone..I am sure that no one can tell you what to do, it is your child and your choice and no matter what there will be consequences.
If she goes, she may risk re-contamination..With each bite, it is Russian Roulette..
No one can tell you that they will watch her every minute..My daughter had gotten lost on a trip to Gettysburg the year before and she was to be with one of the teachers at all times..Well that didn't happen..
If you do not let her go, she may be ostricized or teased forever by those that know the score..And she will harbour anger at you..It is a loose loose situation..
Have you tried to see if you can chaperone the trip?..Even if you pay full price..
Or could you take the trip as a family later this year and permit her to have some of the experiences..Just with less danger..
And I know we should not live in a bubble but having dealt with 9 suicide attempts, if I could go back and make things safer, I would give up body parts to have kept my daughter safer. And no one that does not walk the walk can understand this..
Good luck Di..Will continue to keep you in my prayers. lymemomtooo
ps No one ever mentioned the word tick or lyme disease when they sold parents on the idea of the whale watch..
[This message has been edited by lymemomtooo (edited 17 May 2005).]
map1131
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 2022
posted
ArtistDi, I can so relate to your fears. We've got to be knowledgable and preventive to some extent, but we've got to live life.
Think about this. You could refuse your daughter this outing and next month she could get a tick bite in your back yard.
My grandson is an insect magnet like myself and every time we take him to our lake cabin he ends up being bit by some insect. I spray him and keep him out of the weeds and woods. He loves going with us and I can't take that away from him.
When I look at tall grass/weeds and woods, I see ticks. Others see beauty of nature. When I see deer I think lyme disease. When others see deer they think of Bambi.
We don't want anyone we love (or our worst enemy) to have to go through what we've been through. But we do have to have a life!
Take care, Pam
Posts: 6495 | From Louisville, Ky | Registered: Jan 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
I disagree with 99% of everything that's been said here. This is not the common cold we're talking about. This is a disease that can, and does on a very regular basis, ruin lives in a very big way. To go on a trip because she may be teased or because a cop, however well meaning, says he will watch her is crazy. This is a disease that can give (IMO) MS, Alzheimers, Chronic Fatigue, Parkinsons, Fibromyalgia, ADD, etc etc etc etc etc. Going on this nature trip without anyone who is LL, because we have to live our lives, may end life as she knows it. Please rethink this.
This is my opinion and some of what I've said will offend some. I apologize for that but I believe risking your health, education, sanity, future, etc, and possibly suffering horribly, for the reasons given is foolish beyond measure.
b
[This message has been edited by brainless (edited 17 May 2005).]
Posts: 210 | From lalaland | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
You cannot live your life in fear. And fear is learned. Nervous parents have nervous children. Fear ridden parents have fear ridden children. BUT...I would take precautions.
Posts: 6022 | From Mobile, AL | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
I have no problem with precautions, but to take it to the point of limiting your life...I just dont see it.
Are we not going to go outdoors any longer?
As terrible as Lyme is, we MUST live our lives. That is why I eat carbs, that is why I drink wine...I will live my life despite Lyme disease.
Ticks bite people. Ticks carry diseases. But it also a fact that you dont have to be outside to get a TBI.
[This message has been edited by Kara Tyson (edited 18 May 2005).]
Loribelle
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6293
posted
oh ArtsiDi, i feel for ya. i absolutely understand your fear. (my 'child' is in iraq)
i was REALLY sick last year. the first tick i saw this year made me so angry and SO upset. i cried, grieved, then decided i am going to live my life how i want to and not let the dang bug take that too. BUT i take precautions!
i don't know how old your daughter is, that makes a big difference as far as i am concerned. is she old enough to REALLY take the care she needs to? and mature enough to DO it no matter what? this can be a golden oportunity to teach her how to protect herself...
i am such a nature child (ok, i'm 43) that for ME, to stay out of the woods would be as bad as lyme itself really. i realize tho that not everyone is like me...
i also want to let you know that if you don't let her go it is not the end of the world, and she will get over it. my dad didn't 'believe in' field trips. i never got to go to any of them. i survived. i stayed at the school with the librarian and my sisters... of course i was upset. i now understand my dad's point of view - he just loved me.
those people should not be undermining your efforts as a mother by calling and pleading her case. they should simply have said to her something like "sorry kiddo, that is between you and your mother, and i am sure she has very good reasons! it is because she loves you so very much and she doesn't want you to go through what SHE does."
IMO.
good luck, being a good parent is hard. one quote i think of from time to time is "when we KNOW better we DO better." whatever that means
quote:Originally posted by brainless: I disagree with 99% of everything that's been said here. This is not the common cold we're talking about. This is a disease that can, and does on a very regular basis, ruin lives in a very big way.
I vote for the father/daughter trip. I don't even walk across grass if I don't have to.
Posts: 210 | From lalaland | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
Just Julie
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 1119
posted
Di---
I have read all of the replies, and I did not feel I could post to this because it is something that I have had to deal with myself, with both my sons, and I get pretty het up with the whole situation, but I read OptiMistic's reply, Brainless's reply and Loribelles reply and finally had to chime in.
Forgive my typos, I am trying to type as fast as I can get the thoughts out.
My kids have attended private schools all of their lives-they are now 7th and 10th graders.
Both boys have had these nature/outdoor ed. field trips-first in 7th and 8th, and then again 9th and 10th (high school retreat trips into the mountains in northern CA).
I never felt right about letting them go, so I said "no". I had to first defend my reasonings as to why, and then I had to deal with my son(s) disappointments, and their situations at school, as the other kids found out why they were not allowed to go on these stupid trips.
I handled it as well as I think I could have, having Lyme (brain) myself at the time.
I believe you should repost your query regarding this issue, and title it for parents only.
Your responses here from others who have said that you have to "live your life", etc. meaning not to keep your daughter from going, or even going out where the ticks are, is not going to weigh as much as replies from parents who have kids that have Lyme. Or, even parents who have Lyme, and have kids who have Lyme.
It's just not possible to be objective about this issue. It's not, it's not ever gonna be, and it will not solve itself.
You will not get the magic answer for this dilemma. It will have to be one you tailor to yourself, your family, your situation, and what possible future you will have when you make the decision to either let your daughter go on this trip, or keep her home.
I agree with OptiMisTic, in that you can and have the entire no questions asked, right, to have an alternate assignment given to your daughter, if you choose to keep her home. I did that, and both my boys have had to do the assignment.
What I will now post, is something that I am not sorry I do, or did, and if my son's teachers EVER read this message board, will find out, and I just don't give a damn now.
I DO THE ALTERNATIVE ASSIGNMENT MYSELF. Yep, that's right. You read this right. I told my sons that it is punishment enough to have this @#$% disease. That I do not know if I gave the Lyme to them via pregnancy/breastfeeding, or by hiking with them out in the stupid open space/woods when they were babies/children, so they are not responsible for doing the assignment when it is not "their fault" for not being able to go on the @#$% nature trips that the schools feel the need to pressure them and their parents, to go on.
I feel these nature trips are just excuses to get the teachers out of a week's of teaching. I have found in the 4 yrs of having to deal with this issue (starting with oldest son, and now finishing up with youngest son) that in questioning my son's peers, that NONE OF THEM even remember what the crap is that they were supposed to be "learning". So, since I know that essentially nothing is learned, it is more of a "fun" trip, my son is not missing out on anything more than a possible tick bite and relapse of this very stinkin', incredibly life altering, horrific disease called Lyme.
I cannot type fast enough to get my thoughts out, so if this sounds disjointed, and with no point to it, well, so be it. I get so worked up when I read other people (even those who have Lyme for God's sake) say "oh, well, we can't let it win, we can't let it keep us from living out lives" I say hog wash. I let it keep me from living my life when I let my mind float on the fence on whether I should go out into the tall grass again, or walk in the open space again, etc. and I waffled this way and that.
I found peace, not only for myself, but for my children when I made the decision to just "stay out of it", meaning the places where I KNEW that ticks were likely to be, and in our case, likely to hop on and suck the rest of our lives out of us!
You will find peace when you have made your choice, and stuck to it. Not wishy-washing back and forth.
Take a firm, calm measure with the teachers, make your request known, and then let them deal with whatever fears they may have as a result of the choice you make for your daughter.
Only YOU will know when it's right.
One last point: put yourself (God, for just a brief minute, no longer) in the position of having your daughter come home from this nature trip, and then come running to you, saying (screaming more like it) "mom, MOM!!! THERE'S A TICK IN MY BELLYBUTTON!!!. Picture this. Now, picture, if you will, your reaction. I can't say how the rest of the scenario would go for you, but personally, for me? I would lose it, and I just probably would never come back.
It would just leave me completely undone. Almost like when I found out that not only did I myself have Lyme, but both my kids did too.
The undescribable madness that this has caused in our lives this past 5 years is beyond a single post here on this board, but suffice it to say, no one can relate to this issue, the one you have posted here, unless they have a child with Lyme, and they themselves, as mothers, have Lyme too.
Then, let them give you advice.
As I have, a mother who has Lyme, and who has 2 kids with Lyme.
It is no cake walk. We are here for you. Julie
Posts: 1027 | From Northern CA | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged |
cootiegirl
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 3216
posted
Hey Di. Didn't read the whole thread - just too many words for my holey brain to digest. Looks like the group that has posted is pretty well split.
There has been more hype over the years about school based nature adventures. We have a similar situation with my younger son. His school has had a nature trip for over thirty years! The kids go away for 4-5 days and commune. All the teachers incorporate the experience into their curriculum.
Personally, not being a real nature goddess myself, I've thought the whole thing a bit silly and not necessarily a do or die experience. There are others that share my sentiment, but we don't make a big deal about it because parents have to decide what they want for their kids...Most in my area, as well as the school are totally ignorant about tick borne diseases...
I think when you have experienced what Lyme Disease can do to you one some level, you naturally are going to be more cautious. If nature is a passion for someone and they are sick with Lyme, they will do what they can to still enjoy nature to the best of their ability and that's fine. They won't let the illness stop what they like to do because they believe you can get bit just as easily in your backyard in some areas. I agree that we can't live life surrounded by bubble wrap, but I don't see erring on the side of caution and not having a child participate in such a program as creating undue fear.
I think you have to decide for yourself what comfort level you have. I would look at how critical the experience is to your child's education - do you feel that this experience will benefit her academics? Will it help her move to the next grade? Will it get her into the college of her choice? Will it make her a better person? Can she sleep away under different circumstances?
In our own experience, my son has Lyme and he is being treated for it and coming along great. Do I want to run the risk of him being reinfected? Not a chance and life regardless of how much we try to protect, has been changed. My son loves being outdoors but knows that there are things that must be done to reduce risks. And there are some things he just is not allowed to do right now.
I don't care how much DEET is sprayed on a child, there is no guarantee a grownup will follow up on it, unless a child's parent actually goes along and chaperones. And even then there are no guarantees.
My son is not going on the school nature adventure. He's naturally disappointed because it is the 'thing' to do in his grade. For the kids it's more about sleeping away and not really the academic relevance. But he understands. Am I overprotective? At this point in his life, I don't think so.
Personally I'm more the museum type - I'd rather schlepp a bunch of kids there instead! cootiegirl
Posts: 1728 | From New York State | Registered: Oct 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
You know, I'm kind of surprised that schools are even doing this. A whole week? Basically a camping trip? Do the kids have to pay extra for this? Seems like it would be reather costly.
As a former [FORMER because of Lyme] teacher, I know the liability a school or teacher could be faced with if anything went wrong. I would think the school could even be sued if a child became ill from a tick bite???
I agree that no amount of DEET is going to protect you....and there's no guarantee it will be used, as cootiegirl said.
cootiegirl
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 3216
posted
Yep Tutu...The kids in our area travel downstate to a YMCA sponsored site called Frost Valley. I think it's fairly pricey - somewhere around $300. The kids start fundraising at the beginning of the school year to defray the cost to families. The facility is quite cushy by camping standards - nice cabins, beautiful dining hall so the experience is far from roughing it. You can check out their website at frostvalley.org
Academically there is 'school' everyday. The kids are expected to go on hikes, do experiments, journal, etc. The kids in our area typically go in June (the height of tick season), altho a few classes years ago went in the dead of winter. It reduces the risk a bit...
I would have to agree with you tho as far as liability. I am sure there is some paperwork that parents must sign absolving the schools from problems at some level, but again I don't think vector borne illnesses even cross people's minds in my part of the state, so they are oblivious to that risk factor.
Like I say, most kids look at the experience as really a giant sleep over and a chance to get away from home for a time. My son and a few other kids are staying back. They will go to school as usual and have things to do here. cootiegirl
Posts: 1728 | From New York State | Registered: Oct 2002
| IP: Logged |
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
Wow! These responses couldn't come at a better time...just came home from the hospital for supervised IV and both my hands are bandaged to avoid bleeding under my skin like two weeks ago.
My daughter is 12 years old and won't even sleep over a friend's house down the street. This trip is a 5 day trip in CT, and I made my objections last fall in public at a forum about this trip. I spoke against it, and that it was time to figure out another trip. Yeah, everyone said OK, you figure it out. I just didn't have the energy or resources enough to pull a whole trip together.(I tried calling, emailing places, presenting brochures, but it was vitoed.) Also, other folks who don't have lyme, don't know this horror.
I have been extremely ill for almost five years, and last year, so ill in the summer that I made out my will....couldn't walk, was basically bed-ridden and very weak. I can't just let my child go because I personally don't agree with these trips.
She is only 12, and her Dad is willing to take her and the other kid in her class (who has active lyme) on a trip to Boston to the museums. They can stay with my sister-in-law. My daughter was wearing me down, but thankfully my husband stood firm, and said he knew I would get sick with worrying about her. He doesn't want her to feel she can pull rank after this decision was made in Sept. '04.
I can't do it; the thought of it makes me literally want to get sick to my stomach. I love her dearly and yet, I can't let her do this because last year a kid came home with lyme. At first doctors here didn't recognize the rash because it was "abnormal," and luckily for these folks, the bull's-eye appeared. My friends' kids have gotten bit, and I know that there were ticks in the cabins.
I made this decision a long time ago, and now, all of it is being rehashed with hard feelings between my daughter and me. Do I understand how she feels...I do...I don't blame her for being angry, but I also know that if she came home with a tick bite, I would be devastated, mentally and physically, because I would forever blame myself for knowing better. I couldn't watch her live the life that I barely live.
I don't say she has to stay home--not my intent, but lyme is not a 10-day Doxy cure as many intimate.
Thank you parents with lyme and with kids with lyme for understanding. It is a hard stance to take, but I feel it is a dangerous trip in light of all the lyme found in New England, and CT, of all places!
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
lla2
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2364
posted
I am a lyme patient and have two kids who were terribly sick with lyme, babs and bart...but where do you draw the line? kids have to be kids. YOu can't make htem afraid of life?
If I tried to do that my kids would never go outside, we live in the woods, on a pond....they check themselves and each other every night...but they live nad have fun.
this trip is a social event with friends..part of their growing up with thier friends..something they're all doing togehter..I remember field trips like that back to fourth grade going to alton jones to camp out!
I know you 've made up your mind already..I just wanted to add, that at some point you have to let them enj0y life as it comes, and that does include bumps adn bruises and LYME! Have them learn how to check themselvs as well as cover themselves in DEET;..my kids do it every day adnhave been fine now for 2 years...it can be done and they can go on to enjoy the outdoors and not develop phobia of it, which is where thye're leading to...
I love you di, you know that, but I htink this is a mistake.
Just my two cents.
Lisa
Posts: 4713 | From saunderstown, ri Usa | Registered: Apr 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
I was very worried for you, Di... so much so that I checked this thread several times a day. I'm happy that, in this case, you decided to err on the side of caution.
Giving advice is easy but, if that advice is wrong, few, if any, of us will be at your child's bedside or be as devastated as you will be if she loses her quality of life. You've made my week.
b
Posts: 210 | From lalaland | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
Monica
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 224
posted
Di, I think you need to stick to your guns. This is your child and you must do what you think is best.
No one is implying our children should be afraid of life -- just Lyme disease.
Personally I think this "Nature's Classroom" is a load of crap. How's about we take the kids on the New York or Boston subway system instead? I'll bet there are lots of parents who wouldn't permit that.
Somehow some of us have the mistaken idea that nature is benevolent. Well, it's not. And those of us with tick borne infections are the proof that it is not.
Stick to your guns.
Posts: 1757 | From Somerset County, NJ | Registered: Oct 2000
| IP: Logged |
MADDOG
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 18
posted
Hi,No way would a child of mine,(If I had a child), go on such a trip with out me along inspecting for ticks every night before lights out.
No Way!!!!!!! MADDOG P.S. i would be taking them out to the woods but under supervision of ME!!
Kara Tyson
Frequent Contributor (5K+ posts)
Member # 939
posted
I dont think any of us think that nature is tame, but nature is not evil either.
Posts: 6022 | From Mobile, AL | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged |
Loribelle
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6293
posted
the Lord 'laid you on my heart' today so i checked in to see what you had decided too.
i did not realize that it was a 5 day thing, and she was only 12! i would have said no way, lyme or no lyme, myself... unless MAYBE i was going as chaparone. a day trip is one thing... a week long deal is another. IMO.
too bad the school, and especially the 'cop' who called you, put you in that position of questioning your decision.
Di, i think it is terrific that your husband is taking the girls on a trip of their own! i hope they will appreciate that! also glad that it will not be a miserable week of worry for you. don't look back.
posted
Sorry for butting in again, since I don't have children!
But MADDOG and Loribelle said things that were in my mind, but I didn't express.
I think it would make a big difference if this was only for a DAY and not MANY days, and IF you were there to do the tick checks yourself.
I might venture out into the woods with the kids myself, but I would be reluctant to let someone else be in charge of that and also in charge of doing the tick check.
[and who wants a camp couselor or teacher doing the checking....and what kid would WANT them to!!?? YIKES!] [and if you put the kids in charge of that, how well would it be done??]
Anyway, I know Di has made up her mind, but I just wanted to say that MADDOG and Loribelle said what I was thinking.
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
Well, my daughter kept pushing and I almost caved, giving in. Except, my husband was wonderful! I said, "OK, I give up," and he said, "NO way." He said initially he would have let her go on the Nature's Classroom trip, but with the high incidence of lyme, and with me being so sick, he had decided against it.
Plans changed again...other kid is making different plans, and my daughter is very excited because Dad is taking time off from work and taking her on a train to Canada-- Montreal. Now her Nature's Classroom friends are jealous.
He is going to take her to science-based museums, etc., and the school agreed to reimburse. My daughter will have a wonderful vacation in a new country and she will be safer in my eyes with her Dad. Also, we are having her keep a photo journal.
My husband was incredibly sensitive about this...he said if she came home with lyme, he couldn't live with "me." He said I would feel guilty and get sicker, and he has had a long, rough ride with me.
My daughter only has one really good friend in her class (and she is the only minority in her class and one of 4 in the whole school system)...another issue. She wants to transfer to another school next year because of the cat fights she had with her "friends." She also wants to meet students who are more like her--creative--and expand her cultural base. That is why my husband and I didn't think the "bonding" aspect would be that meaningful to her.
We resolved it, but it was like World War III in our home after the DARE officer called. He made the mistake of telling my daughter he would talk to me, and it put too much pressure on me again. (My husband said my daughter also had to learn the meaning of "no," and since the teenage years are coming, we had to stand firm.) I made this decision in September and signed papers waiving this trip, so my daugher knew way back when that this was the decision.
Right or wrong, I am making this decision, because honestly, I would crumble if she came home with lyme. I would have felt like I could have prevented it, and I know I can't protect her from everything, but this is evil. Our family unit has almost been destroyed at times because of it.
We are at peace now....all of us.
[This message has been edited by ArtistDi (edited 22 May 2005).]
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
cootiegirl
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 3216
posted
Di, Glad to hear there was a resolution that worked for all. I'm all for hands on experiences, even overnight field trips, but weeklong nature adventures are a bit much. It sounds like your daughter's alternative trip with her Dad will be very memorable. cootiegirl
Posts: 1728 | From New York State | Registered: Oct 2002
| IP: Logged |
lymemomtooo
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 5396
posted
It will all be good Di..lymemomtooo
Posts: 2360 | From SE PA | Registered: Mar 2004
| IP: Logged |
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
The school will reimburse for up to six meals for my daughter and the price of admission to any museums. We have up to $110 to use because our family, like all the other families in my daughter's grade, did fund-raising for the class trip. Each kid was allotted $110 from the fund-raising, but still kids going to Nature's Classroom probably had to kick in $150-$200 for the fee and supplies.
At any rate, the principal was terrific at my daughter's school. Unfortunately, we are losing her this year.
I encourage parents to always ask for funding, especially if they participated in the fund-raising. We did the Halloween Festival, breakfasts, and I donated artwork for auction,....so I feel my daughter is entitled to her share of the money collected.
As a side note, did you know that you needed a birth certificate or passport to get into Canada now? My friend, a French teacher at another school (and originally from Canada) said I would also need to have a letter notarized stating that I am giving permission to my husband to take my daughter to Canada. She said by 2008 all people will need passports.
Since my daugher is adopted (Korean), we are also bringing her Naturalization papers. Wow, it gets complex, but the trip is still a "go." They are leaving tomorrow.
Thanks all for listening and offering support as well as opinions.
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
Loribelle
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 6293
posted
YEAH!
i still am mad at the dare officer though! they should get a 'talking to' for interfering. IMO. a police officer, especially in the dare program (!) should know better than to interfere (undermine) in matters of authority (and respect...) of a parent!
lla2
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2364
posted
glad it worked out di...gotta do what's in your heart!
Lisa
Posts: 4713 | From saunderstown, ri Usa | Registered: Apr 2002
| IP: Logged |
valymemom
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 7076
posted
I think a similar question was posed to Long Island Dr. B. at Hope to Heal......a question about sending a child/children to camp.....(couldn't hear if the child/children had already been infected)
His answer was "don't send them"
Posts: 1240 | From Centreville,VA | Registered: Mar 2005
| IP: Logged |
posted
It seems that once again, fear and anger rule the day.
Posts: 133 | From Rocheser, MN, USA | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
Just Julie
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 1119
posted
Hey Steve in MN---your post really offended me. How many kids with Lyme do you have? Do you have Lyme too?
Sorry Lymetoo if I offended YOU, as you made it out to sound with your post later in this thread.
Undermining parents authority seems to rule the day in school land-public and private. You can't seem to get ahead one way or the other without some parent or kid making you (the parent) feel like you're some paranoid anxious fearful parent shielding your child from THE WORLD simply because you made the choice not to go out into tick infested areas any more.
Why is that? What is so wrong with that? Once your life has been so radically altered by having to fight this shi**ty disease, what the hell is wrong with finding *other* things to do in this life, and in this world that will not put you at risk for reinfection.
HMMMM?
Any why, pray tell, does that seem to honk everyone's horn when you make it known to them that you are choosing NOT to put yourself, and your family, at risk to go along with the crowd/herd mentality (MOOOOOO-OOOOOO)and throwing your child (yes, they are still children, folks, in grade school)into the wilds of tick-land, thinking, hoping and trying to believe that some other adult will be as vigilant in tick checks, spraying of DEET, etc, as you.
HEWKWWWWSDDSSSS. Sorry, just coughing up a hairball at the tone of Steve's post.
Ok, I feel much better, now gotta run and get my head back in the sand.
Posts: 1027 | From Northern CA | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged |
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
Decided to delete and not get sucked into a debate that is pointless for me.
[This message has been edited by ArtistDi (edited 25 May 2005).]
[This message has been edited by ArtistDi (edited 25 May 2005).]
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
quote:Originally posted by ArtistDi: Decided to delete and not get drawn into a debate that is pointless for me. I said my piece and I have no regrets about my decision. My husband and child are in Montreal, my child having a train experience seeing country she had never seen. Better than going over the border to CT to be in woods that are literally in our back yard.
Anger did not motivate me...safety and larger life experiences. We're happy.
[This message has been edited by ArtistDi (edited 25 May 2005).]
[This message has been edited by ArtistDi (edited 25 May 2005).]
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
posted
My Daughters School also went to Nature's Classroom this week. She is one of 8 children that did not go out of 120! Her teacher told me that she would have to walk through the woods and fields with tall grass and she could not opt out of those activities! Imagine all of those little children walking in the woods, it makes me sick. I emailed all the principles in my district as well as the superintendant about my concerns with lyme and my lyme history, etc and got this reply "we will pray for you" - nothing about lyme....Now I keep emailing them information about lyme- sooner or later they have to listen. We all need to spread the word to the uneducated public- and yes, I too felt guilt from most everyone about not sending her. I dont care, at least I can sleep at night knowing she is in her own bed and not tromping through the woods.
Posts: 8 | From easton ct usa | Registered: May 2004
| IP: Logged |
posted
My point is that kids and adults are exposed to thousands of risks every day. We, as grown-ups, try to help manage these exposures for our kids based on our understanding of the risks associated.
Statistically kids have a higher chance of being in a serious car accident than contracting Lyme (when appropriate preventative measures are taken). Does this mean that you don't allow your kids to ride in cars? No, you teach them how to manage their risks, such as wearing seat belts, riding in the back seat, driving safely and so on.
But because Lyme sufferers have a unique acute awareness of Lyme Disease, it seems that the world is viewed through a Lyme-tinted filter.
As a parent you have the absolute right to make whatever decisions you feel are appropriate in raising your children--just face the reality that not everyone will always support you.
Posts: 133 | From Rocheser, MN, USA | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
Just Julie
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 1119
posted
Statistically kids have a higher chance of being in a serious car accident than contracting Lyme (when appropriate preventative measures are taken).
WHERE DO YOU GET YOUR "STATISTICS" Steve???
Does this mean that you don't allow your kids to ride in cars? No, you teach them how to manage their risks, such as wearing seat belts, riding in the back seat, driving safely and so on.
Again Steve, I do not think that everytime I drive with my kids in the car, or as I am about to watch my almost 16 y.o. son begin driving, that I think they will become road kill when they park their butts into a car seat. I know they COULD statistically, but also, if they were to be in a car accident, there is not the head knowledge that they will become disabled EACH AND EVERY TIME THEY ARE IN AN ACCIDENT, as I do believe a tick bite seems to indicate-becoming disabled, who knows statistically, each and every time they get a tick bite.
But because Lyme sufferers have a unique acute awareness of Lyme Disease, it seems that the world is viewed through a Lyme-tinted filter.
That's right, my kids are in a Lyme-tinted (yes it's green to go along with the Lime theme) bubble. They are free to break the damn bubble when they turn 18.
As a parent you have the absolute right to make whatever decisions you feel are appropriate in raising your children--just face the reality that not everyone will always support you.
My reality, Steve, is that as a mom with Lyme, with 2 kids with Lyme, I have chosen to prevent (as much as is in my power, because "I'm the mom, that's why") further tick bites.
See, if I let them go off on these #$%^ ignorant *** nature trips, and they come home with a tick in their navel, or under their arm in their pit, will it be because the parent/chaperone in charge of "tick checks" (ha, what a joke-here little johnny, let me look for ticks on you, now pull down your underwear and let me do a complete one) did not do a complete body tick check, or they took off on the nature hike in the heavily wooded brush area, and oh dang, forgot the DEET spray, oh well, lets hurry we don't want to fall behind the group, you'll be FINE this time, we won't forget on the next hike, yeah right.
Reality is that when you know better and you choose to do it anyway, you deserve what you get.
Reality whopped me upside the head in May 2000, and I haven't had the same mindset since. It came on slowly (thank God) but after a few minor "oops" moments, I "got it" and determinedly changed our lifestyle.
Remember, most of us Lyme people got this #$%^ disease because we were "nature" people. Now, because of our nature loving natures, so to speak, we have this crappy future ahead of us and we have to implement the changes for our families too. It sucks, and I wish I could still go out there and be Joe Nature girl, but in my maturity, and putting my children and family ahead of my own selfish personal desires, I gave up that longing to be one with the earth, and now am choosing to make concrete be our friend.
We only get one life, and baby, this is it.
I wasn't gonna post, really I wasn't, but it's attitudes like yours that I got from my sons schools that got my back up, and damn it, I wish I could swear like a sailor, or like DR Wiseass does, but I'd probably get butted off this site forever.
I'm betting my post will be the last one on this thread.
[/B][/QUOTE]
Posts: 1027 | From Northern CA | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged |
It seems to be human nature that we don't have empathy until we've been through the same exact hell.
b
Posts: 210 | From lalaland | Registered: Jan 2005
| IP: Logged |
ArtistDi
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 2297
posted
Yes, there is that old saying..."walk a mile in my shoes."
BTW, my daughter just called me from Montreal and she has had the BEST time there. Loved the Biodome...nature under glass! Ecosystem, penguins, which she had never seen, etc., etc.
I would rather lay down my life and die, then see my kids get as sick as I became. It is difficult not to have fear teach a lesson.
I think of 9/11 and all that fearsome event produced--many govt. enactments for safety, etc. Fear does govern at times to prevent more mishaps. But good compromises can be made without instilling more fears and keeping people safe. In our neck of the woods, a newspaper article just came out stating how lyme has gotten out of control.
When I had my line put in on Monday, one of the surgical nurses asked me to look at another nurse's tick bite...near her belly button. Bite in the middle with pure redness around it, about the size of a half dollar. Now, here's a nurse who had to be told to get treated and tested. (that's scary.)
Posts: 1572 | From Hatfield, MA, USA | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged |
lymebrat
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 3208
posted
Hi DI...
You have to do what you gut instincts tell you to do... you are the mom!
But I do have to say I am surprised by some of the post here.. everyone was just trying to help by giving you advice and sharing their own experiences and opinions...
which is what this board is all about..
Personally, I would have said...
go with your gut, but in my opinion, if your daughter really wanted to go on this trip and was willing to go under your terms...
meaning she gets checked morning and night for ticks...by a school nurse or adult chaperone you trust.. ( also if you are unable to go on the trip and don't trust another to this task, another relative or friend could chaperone..just a thought)
using deet, wearing appropriate clothing..etc..
Then I would have voted or given my opinion that if I were in your shoes, I would let her go. But that's all it is, my opinion...
Someone said somethign about having children and opinions on this topic.......Just because one doesn't have children, doesn't mean they don't have a voice on this board.. IMHO.
I have Lyme, and my 8 year old son and my 6 year old daughter have both been very sick from lyme...
And 12 days ago my daughter was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes... so now she has lyme and diabetes.
But in my case, I feel that I can't let this disease control my life. I gave up hiking and camping with my family for a year..somethign we all loved very much.
We live in the woods of NH and are surrounded by woods, wildlife and have deer in our yard all the time...
So one day, i was sitting in the house and said no more! I wasn't going to let this disease control my life, if I did, in my opinion,.... the disease would have won..
And I won't have it!
So my family and I are all back to camping, and hiking and enjoying our lives. Some of our best memories are the times we have hiked to the waterfalls, and rivers in the White Mountains...
( and for the record, I didn't get lyme while hiking, on a nature trip, or camping.. I was gardening in my own back yard.. and it seems as if I passed it to both of my kids.. so lyme can get you anywhere..unfortunately)
For me, I wouldn't let this disease take those memories away.
Now, I have to worry about taking a child with diabetes on a hike...will her sugar levels get low from the hike, will I give her a snack in time before she passes out?
What if somethign happens to the insulin and her levels go to high...
Now I have a whole new illness to prepare for and try to understand. She will always have to test her blood sugars daily and have insulin shots everyday for the rest of her life...
So while diabetes does require constant monitoring and care, I am determined to not let it rob my daughter of her childhood.
I will do whatever I have to do , to make sure she can continue to do the things she loves...safely!
Sorry if I got a little long winded..I was just trying to say that this is a personal decision..one only you can make..
And that just because I and others offered our opinions that we would let our child go, doesn't mean we are crazy or wrong..it just means that we all make choices that are best for us and our families...
I hope that made sense..I haven't slept more than 3 hours a night since Mikayla was diagnosed with the diabetes...so I'm a little wacky right now
Best wishes and I hope your daughter has a wonderful time!!!!! And always trust your instincts!
~Lymebrat
[This message has been edited by lymebrat (edited 25 May 2005).]
[This message has been edited by lymebrat (edited 25 May 2005).]
posted
Actually Lymebrat did a much nicer job of expressing an opinion similar to mine.
I certainly did not intend to make anyone feel worse than they already do. However, I do think Lymebrat's comment about not letting this disease control our lives is an important point. It seems that so many comments on this board are pre-soaked in fear and anger related to this disease.
I do have Lyme, but assuming that only people with Lyme can have a valid opinion is a bit closed-minded.
Posts: 133 | From Rocheser, MN, USA | Registered: Dec 2004
| IP: Logged |
Lyddie
Unregistered
posted
My kids don't go on the school's nature trips. We do something alternative. If there is an educational component to whatever the school is doing, the school gives us alternative materials.
One of my kids also has diabetes, and the school didn't provide adequate staffing for her to go on a 3 day hiking trip anyway.I was sick with Lyme and couldn't go. The school had intended to base the curriculum on this trip for one month, but agreed not to do this after we had a meeting to ask them not to.
Also, someone from the Federal office of Education, Office of Civil Rights came down and spoke with the school about such trips, at my suggestion. The OCR had a lot of good ideas for alternative trips.
None of this was done in anger and all meetings were pleasant and the school thanked me for raising these issues.
Both my daughters have Lyme as well as me and it isn't easy to treat. I think, like ArtistDi, that some of us have special considerations with Lyme. By that I mean genetic tendencies to autoimmune illness with Lyme (shown by blood tests of genetic markers as well as autoantibody tests). These tendencies make the Lyme much harder to treat and a much more serious proposition to consider.
Getting reinfected is also more serious that getting bitten for the first time.
The way we live is not seriously impacted by fears of Lyme, but we don't live int he woods as some of you do. Honestly, failure to paticipate in these trips has not affected my kids' emotional or social life in any serious way.
My kids have learned to be strong individuals. They do not cave in to peer pressure in other ways because the experiences of being "different" through this illness have made them stand strong. Other kids respect them for it.
Interesting that a DAR officer has pressured you, since the sort of strength to stand on your own that I just described, is the goal of their program.
If you are already dealing with Lyme, and a trip in the woods poses an increased risk of Lyme, and your family genes show a tendency towards big problems with both the illness and the treatment (speaking to ArtistDi and also referring to my own family) then avoiding that risk seems more than prudent.
Next week, my 7th grader is skipping a one-day "bonding" trip in the woods. She is taking an extra dance class, we will go out for lunch, and go to the mall (her choice).
It's not that big a deal. Just risk reduction concerning a horrible illness. Think about other serious illnesses. If a one-time exposure to an insect bite could cause cancer, wouldn't we all do anything possible to avoid the bite? Lyme is not an illness to downplay, at least not in our house.
My oldest daughter has missed months of school due to Lyme, and is certainly "different." I would rather she miss a short trip and be able to stay in school, as she is now able to do.
Lyme hits everyone differently, and maybe there are many different choices that can be made that are all valid. ArtistDI, I am so glad that your choice worked out well.
Just Julie
Frequent Contributor (1K+ posts)
Member # 1119
posted
Lyddie, now why couldn't I just type an eloquent, respective post, the way you just did in yours here today?
You described everything I wanted to say, and feel, so nicely, without sounding strident, and angry, and fearful, as I guess I made my post sound.
thank you for posting such a nicely worded response. As it is already past the fact for Di and her daughter, I still appreciate that you've taken the time to post a very thoughtful and mature position to this subject.
Years later, like 4 maybe? I still can find myself getting very defensive on this topic, even though it is not an issue for my youngest son, now in 7th grade, because I settled this within myself 4 yrs ago when it first came up for my oldest son. Then, it was highly emotional, and very upsetting to find that their private Christian jr. high school teachers were NOT willing to hear me about the Lyme and my concerns, and were NOT going to give us any special considerations.
In fact, their "alternate assignment" was very stressful and did not give me or my son anything to enjoy while the rest of the jr. high were out tromping in the forest "learning" the outdoor ed. curriculum.
Anyway, I'm so glad you were able to post as you did. I, for one, appreciated every single word you wrote. Julie
Posts: 1027 | From Northern CA | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged |
The Lyme Disease Network is a non-profit organization funded by individual donations. If you would like to support the Network and the LymeNet system of Web services, please send your donations to:
The
Lyme Disease Network of New Jersey 907 Pebble Creek Court,
Pennington,
NJ08534USA http://www.lymenet.org/